Prince Of Pierogi Restaurant: Sturgeon Bay Menu
Prince Of Pierogi Restaurant: Sturgeon Bay menu gallery
Choose your favorite dish
Pierogi
AUTHENTIC HOMEMADE POLISH DUMPLINGS WITH TRADITIONAL AND CONTEMPORARY FILLINGS
AUTHENTIC HOMEMADE POLISH DUMPLINGS WITH TRADITIONAL AND CONTEMPORARY FILLINGS
AUTHENTIC HOMEMADE POLISH DUMPLINGS WITH TRADITIONAL AND CONTEMPORARY FILLINGS (VEGAN)
AUTHENTIC HOMEMADE POLISH DUMPLINGS WITH TRADITIONAL AND CONTEMPORARY FILLINGS
AUTHENTIC HOMEMADE POLISH DUMPLINGS WITH TRADITIONAL AND CONTEMPORARY FILLINGS
AUTHENTIC HOMEMADE POLISH DUMPLINGS WITH TRADITIONAL AND CONTEMPORARY FILLINGS
AUTHENTIC HOMEMADE POLISH DUMPLINGS WITH TRADITIONAL AND CONTEMPORARY FILLINGS
AUTHENTIC HOMEMADE POLISH DUMPLINGS WITH TRADITIONAL AND CONTEMPORARY FILLINGS
AUTHENTIC HOMEMADE POLISH DUMPLINGS WITH TRADITIONAL AND CONTEMPORARY FILLINGS
AUTHENTIC HOMEMADE POLISH DUMPLINGS WITH TRADITIONAL AND CONTEMPORARY FILLINGS
More Polish Favorites
AUTHENTIC HOMEMADE CABBAGE ROLLS FILLED WITH BEEF, RICE, ONIONS TOPPED WITH TOMATO SAUCE AND SPICES (G-F)
TRADITIONAL HOMEMADE POLISH DISH. HEARTY AND PACKED WITH PROTEIN! FRESH CABBAGE AND SAUERKRAUT STEWED WITH ONIONS, TOMATOES AND VARIETY OF MEATS - BEEF, BACON AND KIELBASA SERVED WITH A TOASTED BUN (G-F)
WARM BEET SOUP IN A CUP (BROTH ONLY)
WARM BEET SOUP WITH BEEF DUMPLINGS (USZKA)
WARM BEET SOUP WITH MUSHROOM DUMPLINGS (USZKA)
CABBAGE ROLLS FILLED WITH RICE, MUSHROOMS, BELL PEPPERS & ONIONS TOPPED WITH TOMATO SAUCE AND SPICES (G-F)
POLISH SAUSAGE WITH SAUERKRAUT AND CARAMELIZED ONIONS SERVED ON A HORGIE WITH A SIDE OF POTATO CHIPS
DELICIOUS COMBINATION OF KIELBASA, 1 CABBAGE ROLL, HUNTER'S STEW AND 3 CHEESE & POTATO PIEROGI
Polish Crepes
DELICIOUS ROLLED PANCAKES TOPPED WITH SUGAR, WHIPPED CREAM AND FRUIT DRIZZLE
DELICIOUS ROLLED PANCAKES TOPPED WITH SUGAR, WHIPPED CREAM AND FRUIT DRIZZLE
DELICIOUS ROLLED PANCAKES TOPPED WITH SUGAR, WHIPPED CREAM AND FRUIT DRIZZLE
From a reviewer’s perspective, the menu at Prince Of Pierogi Restaurant in Sturgeon Bay offers a comforting and distinctly Polish-inspired selection that feels both traditional and thoughtfully varied. The highlight is clearly the pierogi section, featuring options like Cheese & Potato, Slow-Roasted Pork, Sauerkraut & Mushroom, Potato, Cheddar & Jalapeño, and Spinach & Feta, each reflecting a balance between classic Eastern European flavors and a few modern twists. Beyond the pierogi, the “More Polish Favorites” section adds depth with hearty dishes such as Cabbage Rolls - Gołąbki, Hunter’s Stew - Bigos, and several versions of Barszcz, including Barszcz with Beef Dumplings and Barszcz with Mushroom Dumplings, which together create a strong impression of authentic, home-style cooking. To round out the experience, the menu also includes a dessert-like or lighter touch with Polish crepes, offering sweet choices like Raspberry & Sweet Cheese, Chocolate & Hazelnut, and Strawberry & Cream Cheese, which feel like a satisfying finish to a traditionally savory meal. Overall, even without listed prices, the menu reads as approachable and comforting, focusing on recognizable, well-executed dishes that emphasize heritage and warmth over complexity or trendiness.